EMPLOYMENT APPEALS TRIBUNAL
CASE NO.
RP761/2014, RP762/2014, RP763/2014, RP764/2014, RP767/2014, RP768/2014, RP769/2014, RP770/2014, RP772/2014, RP774/2014, RP775/2014, RP776/2014, RP777/2014, RP778/2014, RP779/2014 RP781/2014, RP782/2014, RP783/2014, RP784/2014, RP785/2014, RP786/2014, RP787/2014, RP6/2016, RP7/2016
MN677/2014, MN678/2014, MN679/2014, MN680/2014, MN684/2014, MN685/2014, MN686/2014, MN687/2014, MN689/2014, MN690/2014, MN691/2014, MN692/2014, MN693/2014, MN694/2014, MN696/2014, MN697/2014, MN698/2014, MN699/2014, MN700/2014, MN701/2014, MN702/2014, MN703/2014, MN9/2016, MN10/2016
APPEAL(S) OF:
Anne Hennessy
and
Julianna Czinkoczki
and
Elizabeth Hand
and
Urszula Kicak
and
Ivans Nikitins
and
Jennifer Pennie
and
Aneta Maciejunas-Ruksc
and
Valentina Palmane
and
Laura Kavanagh
and
Eithne McArdle
and
Mariusz Smigielski
and
Evelyn McDonnell
and
Aneta Smigielska
and
Joanna Morokiszka
and
Valentina Nikitina
and
Galina Kolodinskaja
and
Anita Myers
and
Florence Keating
and
Patricia Hislop
and
Beata Wozniak
and
Joan McKittrick
and
Brenda Kirwan Hammond
and
Olive Traynor
and
Mariea Mulligan
against
Smorgs (Ireland) Limited T/A Travelodge Ireland
and
Glantoir Ri Limited (In Liquidation)
under
REDUNDANCY PAYMENTS ACTS 1967 TO 2014
MINIMUM NOTICE AND TERMS OF EMPLOYMENT ACTS, 1973 TO 2005
I certify that the Tribunal
(Division of Tribunal)
Chairman: Mr. D. Mac Carthy SC
Members: Mr. E. Handley
Ms. M. Maher
heard this case in Dublin on 16 September 2016 and 6 December 2016 and 12 December 2016 and 10 February 2017
Representation:
_______________
Appellant(s):
Mr. Martin Mannion, SIPTU, Liberty Hall, Dublin 1
Respondents
Mr. Joseph Burke, McCartan & Burke, Solicitors, Iceland House, Arran Court, Smithfield, Dublin 7
Mr. Declan McDonald, Liquidator
The decision of the Tribunal was as follows:-
- The claims were conceded by the liquidator of the second respondent and details of pay and dates of service were agreed. As against the second respondent the Tribunal makes awards under the Redundancy Payments Acts, 1967 to 2007, and under the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Acts, 1973 to 2005, as set out in the attached schedule.
- The claims against the first respondent are dismissed.
Name | Employment Began | Employment Ended | Gross Pay | Hourly Rate | Redundancy Payment | Notice period in Weeks | Payment for Notice |
Ms J Czinkoczki | 28/09/2008 | 19/05/2014 | €147.56 | €8.65 | €1,812.04 | 4 | €590.24 |
Ms E Hand | 01/02/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €173.44 | €8.81 | €5,137.29 | 6 | €1,040.64 |
Ms A Hennessy | 13/09/1998 | 19/05/2014 | €190.30 | €8.65 | €6,442.00 | 8 | €1,522.40 |
Ms P Hislop | 15/03/2004 | 19/05/2014 | €330.73 | €9.00 | €7,071.01 | 6 | €1,984.38 |
Ms L Kavanagh | 16/03/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €257.74 | €8.84 | €7,572.40 | 6 | €1,546.44 |
Ms F Keating | 06/05/2006 | 19/05/2014 | €194.65 | €8.65 | €3,324.62 | 4 | €778.60 |
Ms U Kicak | 01/09/2007 | 19/05/2014 | €203.14 | €8.65 | €2,933.34 | 4 | €812.56 |
Ms B Kirwan Hammond | 15/02/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €213.78 | €8.84 | €6,315.06 | 6 | €1,282.68 |
Ms G Kolodinskaja | 20/08/2011 | 19/05/2014 | €118.66 | €8.65 | €771.29 | 2 | €237.32 |
Ms A Maciejunas-Ruksc | 26/06/2007 | 19/05/2014 | €177.33 | €8.65 | €2,624.48 | 4 | €709.32 |
Ms E McArdle | 01/07/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €240.82 | €8.84 | €6,930.80 | 6 | €1,444.92 |
Ms E McDonnell | 26/10/1999 | 19/05/2014 | €211.02 | €8.81 | €6,364.36 | 6 | €1,266.12 |
Ms J McKittrick | 28/02/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €264.02 | €10.16 | €7,778.03 | 6 | €1,584.12 |
Ms J Morokiszka | 23/07/2007 | 19/05/2014 | €192.85 | €8.65 | €2,827.18 | 4 | €771.40 |
Ms M Mulligan | 24/05/2005 | 19/05/2014 | €192.64 | €8.65 | €3,656.31 | 4 | €770.56 |
Ms A Myers | 01/08/1997 | 19/05/2014 | €213.20 | €9.25 | €7,380.98 | 8 | €1,705.60 |
Ms V Nikitina | 14/02/2005 | 19/05/2014 | €187.86 | €8.65 | €3,670.78 | 4 | €751.44 |
Mr I Nikitins | 01/05/2004 | 19/05/2014 | €308.14 | €8.65 | €6,507.92 | 6 | €1,848.84 |
Ms V Palmane | 01/11/2001 | 19/05/2014 | €142.92 | €8.81 | €3,733.07 | 6 | €857.52 |
Ms J Pennie | 01/03/2000 | 19/05/2014 | €214.55 | €8.84 | €6,320.64 | 6 | €1,287.30 |
Ms A Smigielska | 07/02/2007 | 19/05/2014 | €363.67 | €9.65 | €5,658.71 | 4 | €1,454.68 |
Mr M Smigielski | 09/05/2011 | 19/05/2014 | €260.87 | €8.65 | €1,841.74 | 2 | €521.74 |
Ms O Traynor | 01/06/2001 | 19/05/2014 | €185.93 | €8.84 | €5,012.67 | 6 | €1,115.58 |
Ms B Wozniak | 07/11/2005 | 19/05/2014 | €234.05 | €8.65 | €4,231.62 | 4 | €936.20 |
Sealed with the Seal of the
Employment Appeals Tribunal
This ________________________
(Sgd.) ________________________
(CHAIRMAN)